IQ UQ WeAllQ 4IQ

Here's a breakdown of the US election voting patterns based on average state IQ.

Note that this is a hoax. Thanks for pointing that out Bryan.

Posted by dustin on November 4, 2004 with category tags of

4 comments
Much though my inner liberal is burning with rage these days (I hope it's rage, anyway... I knew I shouldn't have slept with that prostitute), I have to point out that this is fairly misleading:

1. Conflating the mean state IQ with the modal state political preference doesn't really tell you anything about how IQ and political preference are correlated for individuals within that state. Implying this would get you summarily laughed out of any social science faculty in the world.

2. As Alice's map shows, Democratic voters are clustered around urban centres. Urban centres=more universities=higher IQ tests. But this CORRELATION doesn't prove that higher IQ causes one to vote Democrat, nor does it prove that going to university causes one to vote Democrat. It proves that the sorts of people who vote Democrat are the sorts of people who also go to university in urban centres (viz. people who have liberal parents).

3. IQ doesn't measure intelligence in any kind of meaningful way, and is notoriously unreliable anyway. That 28-point difference between the highest state and the lowest state is actually within the margin of error for tests conducted on a single individual. See, eg.: http://www.audiblox2000.com/dyslexia_dyslexic/dyslexia014.htm.

Sorry to be such a sociological geek, and I assure you that I did vote Democrat. But I feel that this sort of statistical abuse is uncalled for and misleading.
   comment by goodladd (#144) on November 4, 2004

Yeah, I agree with what you say. I posted it because I thought it was funny.
   comment by dustin (#1) on November 4, 2004

It's actually a hoax: http://www.isteve.com/Web_Exclusives_Archive-May2004.htm#38115.6465670139
   comment by Bryan (#22) on November 4, 2004

Well in that case I'm sorry for wasting everyone's time. By the way, did anybody hear that they're taking the word 'gullible' out of the dictionary?
   comment by goodladd (#144) on November 5, 2004

   

VorgTag Cloud

Written by dustin
Latest Photo
Quote of Now:
Friends
Popular Posts
Computer Games

Hey You! Subscribe to dustin's RSS feed.
Or get wider opinion in the Vorg All Author feed.

 
 

Members login here.
© Vorg Group.